Wendy Puff Pizzeria + Pub - Eureka, Illinois

Natasha Z.

Went here for our 9th anniversary! We loved the entire experience the owners clearly love and are passionate about what they do. We were a lol disappointed they were so busy some of the items we came for were sold out but that's a testament to their success. It's always popping so make sure to make a reservation. If you are gluten free this us such a great option as it's THE BEST gluten free pizza I've ever had. And calling them pizzas is selling it short these are artful flavors.

Brian J.

Great food! Great service! Awesome atmosphere! Stopped in to try a couple pizzas and we weren’t disappointed at all. I highly recommend the Wendy City. A touch on the spicy side but not hot by any means. Tons of flavor in the sausage and combined with the cheese, basil and perfectly cooked crust I’d give it a 10/10. Pizzas (puffs) are around 12” in size, cut into quarters.

Nick T.

Awesome gem of a spot, cannot recommend enough! Food was amazing, service was great and friendly and the setting was very cool! Do yourself a favor and visit (repeatedly)! Best pizza in the area

Anastasia L. ?.

We received a gift card for Wendy Puff over the holidays & were so excited to try this local pizza place!
The pizza is a thin crust that has a great puffed crust around the edge to hold on to. The menu is all pizzas (puffs) with a few salads & handful of appetizers, as well a full drink menu.

Each pizza feels elevated with the flavors fully thought out– no boring pizzas here! On the ‘Pedro the Elect’ the chicken meatballs were incredibly flavorful & the white bean chili reduction added a lovely depth to the pesto! We also had the ‘The Soppressata’ & ‘The Green Hornet’ pizzas.
There were gluten free crust & vegan cheese options available.

The staff was super friendly & happy to answer my questions/offer suggestions. One of the owners (2 brothers) checked in on our experience. It was great to meet him & share how delicious meal was!

Making a reservation is recommended because the restaurant is smaller & seating is limited, but there were a few seats available at the bar during both our visits.

Wendy Puff is worth the short drive from Peoria to Eureka & we will definitely be back!

Kyle K.

Good Lord this place is great! My wife and I went there on a date, and we both absolutely loved it. We both had the Bourbon Puff Sour to drink, and it was so good we had to each have a second one. We also thoroughly enjoyed both our pizzas. The staff were really attentive and the owner made sure we were enjoying our visit. The atmosphere is also really great and the place was packed because of how amazing it is! You won't regret a visit to here and it's well with the drive!

Also, I was enjoying my food and drinks so much that I forgot to take pictures before I got into them. The drinks are served to the brim!

Steve D.

Wow!!! What a gem! So quaint, so accessible, so cute! 6 pm reservation on a Saturday night, fast & efficient. Our server was awesome! Couple glasses of wine (they have a large beer, wine & craft menu). Ordered a spicy sausage & veggies, and a sausage on a gluten free crust. This is the best GF crust I have ever had, hands down! The owner, Mr. Mayo came by to check in on us, which was very nice. This was our first time, and perfect for date night or families. Reservations are recommended. Cost is very reasonable and I was shocked at how fast our pizzas came out. 5+ stars!!!!

9/21/2024-Second time here. Place was packed for a 5:45 PM reservation. Wife had red devil pizza and I had the sausage with gluten free crust. Service was still really great, large parties of 4-8, vibe was awesome. Food was excellent! Couple glasses of wine and pizzas 🍕 were less than $68.00 plus tip. They are very efficient, as our pizzas were out in about 10 minutes. Definitely recommend making reservations! We’ll be back sooner than later as this little gem is one of our new “go to” places for us!!!

1/25- Third time! Place is packed, service is awesome, wife and I both had the sausage “puff”. Sam, our server was great! Very reasonable pricing. Worth the drive from Peoria or Bloomington. Definitely make reservations! We shall be back! Oh, got to finally take a picture of the “WendyPuff” oven and have a conversation with both owners! Great dudes! They are hands on! Still the best GF crust I have had in years!

Katana V.

My family and I saw this place advertise on the news and wanted to try it ever since. Don’t let the small menu option steer you away because Wendy Puff Pizzeria + Pub did not disappoint. For appetizers we got the Italian Street Food and Cinnamon Sugar Knots. Out of this world! I would definitely get the Cinnamon Sugar Knots again! For the Puffs which is their pizzas, we got the Sausage + and The Wendy City. They look almost the same but the Sausage + has a bit of garlic taste as The Wendy City has a bit of spice to it, but not overly spicy! I definitely have other puffs already in mind to try during our next visit and of course along with the cinnamon sugar knots! ツ For two appetizers, two puffs, and 3 soft drinks our total was $67, just to give you an idea on price.

I would suggest making a reservation before dining in with all the advertisements and them being so new in a small space. They do accept walk-ins, but you might have to wait awhile for a reservation to clear. We went on a Thursday night and they were full. But the staff were very friendly and they got us a table for 3 as soon as they could.

Sagan D.

The experience was AMAZING! Service by Justin was incredible. The “puffs” were chewy and delicious - an exceptional taste. You can tell they use all high quality ingredients. They also have a great selection of wine and beer - they had my favorite on the menu -Mussel Bay’s Sauvignon Blanc! The interior has been very well designed and fits the space they have. I highly recommend Wendy Puff for this pizza experience. 10/10 will definitely eat here again and recommend to friends!